Creatine vs Whey Protein – Which is Better and Why? Question Answered!

Jeff Baldelli
Written by
Last update:

Short and Sweet: Let Me Explain the Difference Between Creatine vs Whey Protein

There are countless questions posted on these forums each day. So, we collected some of the most common questions and set out to answer them for you. Which one do you want answered?

Creatine vs Whey Protein

Creatine has been used for more than sixty years. It boosts your ability to build lean muscle mass so that your body is able to perform optimally.

Whey protein is an inexpensive and anabolic supplement that helps you build and repair muscles and gives you a much-needed boost of energy.

Both have been used by athletes for years, and they have been proven effective.

First, let’s talk about carbs. It’s recommended that you get about 50% of your calories from carbohydrates. This is important for a lot of reasons. One, your body needs carbs to function and keep your brain active. It also likes to store energy as glycogen for later use. Glycogen is created during the process of breaking down the carbohydrates you consume.

Another way that carbs help out your muscles is through insulin. Your muscles pulls glucose out of your blood stream using insulin. Both creatine and whey protein are made up of simple proteins that your body takes directly to your muscles and doesn’t need insulin to get to them.

What is Creatine?

Creatine is one of the most popular sports nutrition supplements available. It has also become the most popular supplement among softball players and many other athletes who depend on their fast twitch muscle fibers the most.

As the name suggests, it’s a compound produced naturally in the human body. This compound is produced in our body as if it’s a protein.

Our liver aids in its production and is present in the form of phosphocreatine in our muscle tissue. It aids us in the production of ATP, and it quickly becomes one of our body’s energy molecules.

Creatine is found in three different forms. They are:

Creatine monohydrate – It is by far the most commonly used and is the most effective for increasing strength and helping your muscle strength to increase.

Creatine citrate – This is one of the most popular forms and is the most common type of creatine monohydrate. It has the same benefits as creatine monohydrate but only in different dosages.

Creatine nitrate – This form of creatine is considered to be potentially dangerous. It’s the most “explosive” form as this type will mix well with liquid and is absorbed quickly during digestion.

What is Whey Protein?

Whey is a by-product of cheese, also known as “dairy protein”. Whey protein is made by separating dairy fat from the protein is has been acid treated.

Whey protein is fast digesting, meaning it is quickly digested and enters the bloodstream, where it can be used as fuel.

For that reason, it has been used as a recovery from exercise supplement since the 1960’s. Because of its high protein content, it’s also a great source of essential amino acids, a component of protein that serves as the building blocks of muscle.

Pros and Cons of Creatine and Whey Protein

Understanding the differences between Whey Protein and Creatine is important in helping you to determine the benefits of each.

Pros of Creatine

Creatine isn’t the only protein shake that people drink after a workout session. Lots of people rely on whey protein powders to build muscle.

As far as benefits go, there’s no question of which one is better. However, creatine has its following for a reason.

Here are some of the reasons why.

Longer Supply

When you compare the benefits of whey vs. creatine, one of the noticeable differences is that creatine is easy to store. The substance is in powder form.

For some people, it could be inconvenient to carry whey protein powder around. However, since it’s a powder, they can just place it in their shopping carts.

More Efficient

As already stated, creatine is a substance that’s already in a powdered form. What this means is that it’s easy to take with you. It doesn’t require the level of blending or preparation that whey protein does.

This makes creatine a more efficient pre- and post- workout powder.

Greater Focus

The powder concoction of creatine is great for after your workout because it’s more concentrated. The increased concentration of the compound makes it a better option.

Cons of Creatine


The only real drawback to using this product is using it to gain muscle. Most people do not require extra creatine, so it’s a waste if you just take it.

The other drawback is any issues it may cause within the digestive system or the detox system.

These are the only two drawbacks that we could find though. These two are such small elements of the product that they do not outweigh the benefits.

There are also some supplements that are very beneficial that you can get from this organic supplement. One of them is that it can boost your energy instantly. You may suffer from depression. It can also reduce it. You will also be able to stop any episodes of depression if you take this. It’s excellent for increasing strength, as well as muscle mass. It’s even good for increasing bone density.

All of these benefits are wonderful. Many strong men use this to build muscle so it should work for a man or woman. It can make a person more flexible, and flexible people who do not get broken easily are often the strong ones. It is also great for fat loss. It can make you lose fat, especially if you have added creatine. Creatine can be used to boost the immune system and increase the stamina.

Pros of Whey Protein

Protein powders are the miracle cure of the modern world. Are protein shakes really capable of helping you gain so much muscle and lose so much fat? Read on to find out the true facts.

Cons of Whey Protein

Whey protein is the most popular type of protein powder around. The reasons for this are simple: it’s cheap, easy to take, and easy to drink. Drinking a shake post-workout is a great way to help your body recover from a workout quickly. Unfortunately, it’s not the most effective form of protein available.

Quite a lot of the molecules in whey protein are destroyed during the manufacturing process. This may result in a lower than advertised protein content, and also means that your body will have trouble fully absorbing the protein.

The protein molecules themselves also tend to be quite small. Your body cannot absorb a very small protein molecule as easily as it can absorb a large one. This will result in lower absorption rates, and also means that your body will have to break it down into amino acids at a faster rate.

The extra work your body has to do to break the protein into smaller pieces means that your body is less efficient at using the protein. Not only this, but it will also mean that your body will just leave the excess protein sitting in your gut, where it will be stored as fat. In order for the protein to be properly digested, your body needs to slowly break it down into smaller pieces, but this is difficult if the molecules are already small.

Can You Take Creatine and Whey Protein at the Same Time?

Many people are concerned about excess consumption of protein from their diet which might lead to kidney damage. But what many people don’t know is that you can safely take creatine and whey protein together because they can offer you many health benefits at the same time.

This is especially true if you are a bodybuilder. Doing weight training and endurance exercises with high metabolism activities can wear out your muscles very quickly. To keep them healthy and your body performing at its best, make sure you are supplementing your diet with both whey protein and creatine at the same time.

This should help you build muscle faster while you reduce your recovery time.

Protein from whey improves your overall athletic performance by driving the muscle protein synthesis. This translates as your muscle building process and it is very important for building strong muscles.

Creatine, on the other hand, is a great choice for building lean muscles. As a matter of fact, it’s so efficient in building lean muscles that it’s added to many protein powders.

You should, therefore, ensure that the protein powder you take contains the right creatine amounts for your needs. Remember, getting the right dose of protein together with creatine can help you build muscles, improve your athletic performance, and boost your body’s immune system.

If You Can Only Take One Supplement, Which Should You Choose Creatine or Whey Protein?

In the last few decades, constant research has shown that supplementing the diet with creatine can provide many health benefits. While it’s not a “magic pill” that will instantly and completely change you life, it’s an incredibly useful supplement that can help you reach your goals when you combine it with a healthy diet and exercise regimen.

Like most other bodybuilding supplements, it will work best when you combine it with proper diet and exercise. I’ll discuss how creatine and whey protein work with your body and how you can use them to reach your goals in the sections below.

Creatine and Weightlifting

Weightlifting builds muscle mass by breaking down muscle fibers through exercise and recovering them through protein synthesis. When you take creatine in the form of a supplement, it can help you with your recovery. Of course, you always need to eat properly, but a creatine supplement can give you an additional edge.

Because of the health benefits, you may want to include whey protein in your diet if you are spending long hours at the gym or you simply work a lot, which means that you may have to skip meals or eat at odd hours.

Which Option is Better for Building Muscle?

If you are interested in building muscle, which supplement should you take, whey protein or creatine? You will read a lot of info and claims and you probably can’t decide which one to choose. Follow this advice and you can make an informed choice. First, you should know that neither of them will have a negative effect on your body, and both of them will help you build lean muscle. When you exercise, your body undergoes a process of building new the tissues. This requires amino acids that your body either gets through food or supplements. When you exercise and do strength training, this will increase the demand for amino acids.

It is then important that you take a supplement to supply the body with the necessary amino acids. It is also important that you regularly consume the amino acids needed by your body. The protein is also important because they help slow down the process of muscle breakdown. Both options you have are quite good, which is why it’s quite natural to ask which one is better. They are pretty much the same and the amount of amino acids they provide is the same. The only difference is what the body does with the amino acids. Your body uses whey protein more quickly. Most people prefer t take whey protein first thing in the morning and then later on in the day some also prefer to take a dose of creatine.

The Final Word: If You Have to Choose One